It’s easy to see why the pseudo-silent film, The Artist has emerged as this year’s darling in the Best Picture race. Its nostalgia for cinema’s yesteryear is emblematic of an increasingly visible trend in Hollywood lore to romanticize the analog days. But The Artist sets itself apart from other works pining for the past because it is built entirely on a gimmick. Playing to broad traditions and styles of 20’s cinema, screenwriter and director Michel Hazanavicius tries to embody Hollywood’s golden age while lamenting the inevitable progress of technology. That’s about as far as it goes regarding thematic depth. The film’s real showcase is how skillfully it manipulates and presents film form. In this regard, Hazanavicius serves up a few particularly inventive visual tricks and every so often teases us with moments of compositional beauty. But the story's focus on the tragedy of a silent star's fall from prominence and how the guilt-stricken Vamp revives him is askew. So unless I am missing deeper significance of the mimicry and layers of meta-ness, The Artist amounts to little more than a stylistic exercise, albeit a modestly enjoyable one. Even so, Hazanavicius’ emphasis on style and simple storytelling is not what dogs The Artist. That it is a copy and a gimmick bears little relation to the deeper truth that this film lacks a soul. (Michel Hazanavicius, 2011) **
[Note: I'm currently penning a longer essay that looks at the film in a different critical context.]
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Friday, February 3, 2012
50/50
For a movie about a person stricken with cancer, 50/50 goes down pretty easy. That it is so pleasant to watch makes it a distinctive entry in the cancer movie lexicon, if also a problematic one. Based on screenwriter Will Reiser’s own experience with cancer, 50/50 fearlessly takes on a difficult subject—a young person facing death—and treats it with even amounts of reverence and humor. On hand for the laughs is Seth Rogen, who once again serves up his foul-mouthed but cuddly schtick. There are a handful of knockout moments, most stemming from the subdued sensitivity with which Joseph Gordon-Levitt plays the central character. If only the storytelling were approached with the same grace and knowingness as its thematic core. The narrative is too clean. Gordon-Levitt’s strong performance, for example, helps conceal the fact that his character is too good to be true. It’s as if the filmmakers are screaming from the rooftops, “Look at how promising this kid’s future was before he had cancer!” In the same vein, the closure given to nearly every relationship and plot thread diminishes the film’s impact and nearly compromises its nimble sensibilities. These problems may account for how 50/50 pulls off such a delicate balance and yet fails to resonate as strongly as it should. (Jonathan Levine, 2011) **½
Thursday, February 2, 2012
Page One: Inside the New York Times
The pillars of print media have shown a remarkable inability to adapt to the changing conditions imparted by digital media in recent years. This and the subsequent decline of traditional media represent the compelling narrative at the heart of Andrew Rossi’s documentary. The film explores the shifting media market through the prism of several journalists at the New York Times. Among the reporters on the proverbial front lines of the precipice is David Carr, a quick-witted former addict who regularly “vaporizes” those who decry the Times and traditional media in general. Carr is a fascinating screen subject and a unique voice in the media wars. The film, however, lacks its own voice. In its rapid surveying of the numerous factors in the changing media landscape, Page One fails to make coherent case about any specific or broader point. Rossi goes to great lengths to portray the Times as a storied institution with a rich history and reputation for journalistic excellence (which it is, albeit less so in recent years), though his reasons for doing this are unclear within the context of the film’s greater purpose. While I prize ambiguity in most films, I expect informed accounts on the current state of journalism to be clear and articulate, neither of which can be said about Page One. At one point during the film, Carr overturns the familiar Marshall McLuhan phrase and suggests that with media services like Twitter, the message is in fact the medium. The problem with Page One is that it adopts the same logic. It eschews a cogent journalistic argument in favor of a barrage of messages as ephemeral as a tweet. (Andrew Rossi, 2011) **
Monday, January 30, 2012
Cave of Forgotten Dreams
Friday, January 27, 2012
Win Win
* I don't dislike the Wes Anderson aesthetic. Nevertheless, it has become tired and often itself a cliché akin to the very contemporary tropes Anderson ostensibly is out to undermine.
Monday, January 23, 2012
Rise of the Planet of the Apes
Like so many blockbuster types from last year, Rise of the Planet of the Apes offers a handful of near-remarkable images. The problem—as with much of its big-budget brethren—is that these images and moments are buried within a heap of bland storytelling and direction. I credit the film with excelling in places where many other contemporary blockbusters fail: It has a sense of stakes, a basic competency with its action sequences, and at its core a brilliant performance courtesy of Andy Serkis and Weta Digital. But for every close-up of pixilated wonderment there are countless contrivances that undermine any possibility of intrigue. Each character is fodder for a brutally mechanical plot. You have the good-willed but idiotic scientist, the sadistic aide at the abusive care center, and, yes, even the intelligent girlfriend who has almost nothing to do except look pretty and kiss the hero in a dramatic moment. These are what remain long after the images of dramatic Golden Gate showdown fade into a collective memory bank already overfull with battle scenes. (Rupert Wyatt, 2011) **
Thursday, January 19, 2012
Beginners
Monday, January 16, 2012
Moneyball
Sunday, January 15, 2012
Cowboys & Aliens
Friday, January 13, 2012
The Hangover: Part II
Thursday, January 12, 2012
New directions
The capsule review.
I have avoided short write-ups for some time, mostly because it isn't a terribly exciting model for film writing. But I have recently concluded that for too long this has been my excuse to simply not write. And given the current state of the site, I'll take any writing to no writing at all. Moreover, while good capsule reviews are something of a rarity, this is less a statement about the form than it is a reflection of the difficulty of penning concise, interesting accounts of a film. Some of the best writing I have read recently has been of this variety, and it is about time I start pressing myself to explore it. Short and concise have not exactly been trademarks of my writing o'er these last five years of The Cinematic Art. So, in truth, I take this as a challenge. All news films I see in the theater or at home will receive a short review—probably no more than 200 to 250 words. I may pepper in some reviews of older films, though these will be less frequent.
It is my hope that I still find the time and energy to write commentary pieces on film criticism or a certain trend in film. These pieces tend to represent my preference for writing in this format. But they also require more time and inspiration than I have had lately. Nonetheless, I hope to still chime in to the larger discussion of this great circuit of film writing on the web, even if my contributions are not regular. In the mean time, for the foreseeable future, the capsule review will become this blog's identity.
From a personal viewpoint, I find that I am happier when I write. It is a daunting, often frustrating act for me. It always seems impossible. I write for my day-job in a very different format, and while the task at hand is different the challenge remains the same. Going from blank page to something useful and maybe even interesting is always a source of stress. However, the process is where real discovery happens. Writing helps me to better understand my response to a given movie, or a particular moment within a movie; a shot, a line of dialogue, an edit, etc. Movies are made up of so many things and criticism is a way not only to try to understand how movies work, but more importantly how movies (and art in general) can provoke our innermost states and burrow into our conscious and unconscious minds. For me, writing offers the ability to understand, hone, and develop those thoughts and feelings; which is why I am making a concerted effort to regain some direction for the site.
As always, thanks for reading and I invite your feedback.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)